THE OFFICIAL WHITE HOUSE BOYS ORGANIZATION
IF YOU HAVE NOT SIGNED UP WITH THE NEW ATTORNEYS, YOU MUST CONTACT THEM. HERE IS THE INFO:
CONTACT INFO FOR OUR ATTORNEYS:
727-896-3641 (phone)
727-895-3559 (fax)
email: ghoag@mastersonlaw.com
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
The following are letters and info from Greg Hoag at Masterson Law:
IF YOU HAVEN'T ALREADY DONE SO, YOU MUST CONTACT OUR NEW ATTORNEYS:
Holland & Knight
100 Norlh Tampa Street. Suite 4100 Tampa, FL 33602 | T 813 227.8500
F 813.?29.0134
Holland & Knight LLF
www.hklaw.com
Joseph H. Varner, lll
(813) 227'6703
joevarner@hklaw.com
-------------------------------------------------------------------
September 29,2011
Special Master Tom Thomas
417 House Office Building
402 South Monroe Street
Tallahassee, Florida 323 99- I 300
Re ; Senate Bill 46 - Victims of Florida Reform School far Boys v. The Florida
Department of Juvenile Justice
DOAH Case No. 1l-4100CD
Dear Special Master Thomas:
This firm has been retained to serve as co-counsel for the claimants in the above referenced Claim against the State of Florida's Department of Juvenile Justice (the "Claim"), We currently represent more than 300 individuals (the "Victims") with respect to the Claim presented in Senate Biil 46 (the "Bill"), all of whom were Incarcerated by the State of Florida at the Florida Reform Schools for Boys during the 1940's, 1950's, and 1960's and suffered atrocious abuse at the hands of this State's employees.
This letter responds to your communication dated September 9,2011. You, as Special Master, stated that the Victims' Claim is "not ripe for consideration" based upon an Failure to exhaust "all available administrative and judicial remedies," as required by Rule 5.6(c) of the Florida House Of Representative ("House Rule 5.6(c)". You further demanded that the Victims show that the Bill is ripe for Consideration, or it will be placed in abeyance.
By way of brief background, a small number of the Victims, all of whom this firm now Represents, previously brought suit on behalf of themselves, and those similarly situated, against multiple state Agencies seeking to recover damages for the atrocities that each was subjected to while incarcerated at the Florida Reforrn Sshools for Boys. Not surprisingly, the case was disrnissed based upon the fact that the claims asserted Were barred by the applicable statute of limitations. See "Order Dismissing Plaintiffs' Amended Ccmplaint with Prejudice as to All Defendants," attached as "Exhibit A." It is undisputed that the same barrier to justice stands in the Way of each and every one of the more than 300 Yictims, if they were each to file suit in the appropriate Florida Circuit Court.
Because all of the Victims' claims against the State are clearly barred by the statute of Limitations, we respectfully disagree with ycur position regarding the Victims' failure to exhaust all available Administrative and judicial remedies. As indicated in your letter and pursuant to House Rule 5.6 (c), in the absence of a written settlement agreement a claim bill will be held in abeyance until the exhaustion of administrative and judicial Remedies. This exhaustion ,requirement, however, appears in a variety of administrative and judicial settings and is Often subject to what is known as a "futility exception." Many jurisdictions-including Florida courts will not require a Party to undertake the futile gesture of pursuing relief that is clearly unavailable. See e.g" Lost Tree Yill. Corp. V. City Of Vero Beach,838 So. 2d'561,571 (Fla.4th DCA 2002) (acknowledging the futility exception to the ripeness
Requirement in the context of judicial review of a taking claim); S Florida Blood Bank, Inc. V. Futch,764 So' 2d 724,
726 6tu. +ttr DCA 2000) (citing to McGraw v. Prudential Ins. Co af Am", 137 F.3d 1253, 1264 {10th Cir. 1988) for the
Proposition that the furility exception is limited to situations in which resort to an administrative remedy would be "clearly useless"); McKee v. City of Tallahassee,664 So. 2d 131,334 (Fla. Lst DCA 1995) (rejecting a futility argument Because a party had not submitted a meaningful application for a variance); Tinnerman v. Palm Beach County,641 So' 2d 523, 526 (Fla. 4th DCA 1994) (holding that tutility could be established by submitting one meaningful Application to a zoning board, after which futher attempts could be deemed futile); Lambert v. Blackwell,l34 F.3d 506, 518 (3rd Cir. 1997) (observing that futility can exist where exhaustion of judicial remedies is impossible because of a Procedural bar "such as a statute of limitations"); Henry v. Horn,218 F. Supp, 2d 671,682,692-693 (E.D. Pa. 2002) (reviewing a habeas petition requiring a petitioner to exhaust all available remedies in state court and. Holding that The futility exception applied in this case because the applicable statute of limitations barred the petitioner's state Court remedy).
Based upon the outcome of the lawsuit described above, and the legal authority Referenced in this letter, any future attempt by any of the Victims to obtain judicial or Administrative relief in this matter would be utterly futile. Furthermore although this firm and the Victims greatly respect the procedures established by the House of Representatives in accordance with article III, Section 4 of Florida's Constitution, to file more than 300 individual actions against the State solely to have them dismissed would be a drastically inefficient use of the State's funds and would needlessly consume the precious and limited resources of our judiciary. In addition, to require that these claims be prosecuted would undermine the bar's ethical responsibility to abstain from filing frivolous actions, knowing that they are barred by the statute of limitations.
We firmly believe that the wasted flrnds expended by the State to dispose of any additional cases should be put to a much better use compensating the Victims who suffered untold pain and suffering during (and since) their incarceration by the State. In light of the Victims' distaste for such a wasteful and unnecessary course of action, we respectfully request that you reconsider your determination that the Clairn is not ripe or, in the alternative, recommend a waiver of House Rule 5.6{c) based upon the principles of futility, common sense, efficiency, and practicality.
If you still deem it necessary for the Victims to take the above-described course of action in order to ripen their claims for consideration by the House of Representatives, please so notify us in writing by October 7, 2011. In addition, if we are incorrect in our understanding regarding your opinion as to the reason the Victims have failed to exhaust all available administrative and judicial remedies, please inform us and clarify your reasoning for this failure by the same date, so that the Victims may proceed accordingly. We look fcrward to your response.
Sincerely,
Holland & Knight LLP
Joseph H. Varner, 111
Enclosure
cc: Thomas D. Masterssn, Esquire
Gregory J. Hoag, Esquire
Mark Buell, Esquire
James D. Beach, Esquire
Bradford D. Kirnbro, Esquire
There are TWO Important items below, with the most recent one first. PLEASE read them both!
Info on 2012 Claims Bill (Submitted by B. Middleton)
Subject: FSB Senate Bill (Second Edition for 2012)
This morning I received a copy of the "New" Claims Bill from Greg Hoag, one of our attorneys with Masterson Law Group. The second addition of the Claims Bill was submitted by Senator Mike Fasano for consideration with the Florida Legislature during the next session in Tallahassee. I believe every effort should be made to contact our Florida Representatives and request they support this Bill. Additionally, all WHB's and family members should make a concerted effort to write or call Senators Fasano's office and express their sincere gratitude for his efforts with supporting us. Senator Fasano is one of the "Good Guys" in Tallahassee and is fully behind us and truly believes we are due compensation for the abuse we suffered at Marianna and Okeechobee.
Bryant E. Middleton
To View the 2012 Claims Bill in PDF Form, click HERE, or in WORD or OPEN OFFICE, NOTEPAD, ETC click HERE The entire text is also in the right hand column of this page.
Webmaster's note: Men, this is the time to contact Legislature and ask them to support the bill. Senator Fasano's info follows:
Senator Fasano
#406 Senate Office Building
404 South Monroe Street
Tallahassee, Fl 32399-1100
850-487-5062
or
8217 Massachusetts Ave
New Port Richey, Fl 34653-3111
727-848-5885
The following is from Greg Masterson
Gentlemen:
I am writing to provide an update on the status of the claims bill and our efforts. As many of you already know, our lobbyists recently elected to bow out and decided that they can no longer pursue the claims bill. They strongly believed in the FSB bill, but indicated that the current state of our economy and state’s budgetary problems were major factors in their decision, which we also believe are very real concerns. We have been told that there were NO personal injury claims bills that passed this last legislative session, despite a number of them that were filed. Like ours, many were unfortunately never even considered. Without the lobbyists involved, we realized that we as your legal team faced an uphill battle if we decided to continue pursuing the claims bill since we have no experience lobbying in Tallahassee. We have previously tried to hire other lobbyists without any success, so it was decided that we would contact the Holland & Knight (H&K) firm in Tampa, which is the firm that pursued the Rosewood claims bill. H&K is a very large, highly regarded firm, and, since they were successful with getting the Rosewood claims bill passed, we know that they have experience with these types of claims bills. We are very happy to report that H&K has decided to get involved with the FSB claims bill. Our firm as well as the others will still stay involved with the bill, but H&K will serve as lead counsel. The claims bill was recently re-filed again by Senator Fasano. We are in the process of providing all client names & contact information to H&K. We will have a mass mailing to all clients in the near future to advise them of this news & have everyone sign new fee contracts to include the H&K firm.
Be advised that we still likely face a very difficult road ahead in terms of having the bill considered and passed, and it could very well take several years. However, we are very encouraged by H&K’s involvement, and look forward to working with their firm in pursuit of the bill. We still have very strong feelings about the abuse and tragedy that went on at FSB, and remain vigilant in our pursuit of justice.
We will be in touch soon.
Kind regards,
Greg
RE CLAIMS BILL!
POSTED MARCH 9, 2011
The Claims Bill for Relief for Victims of Florida School for Boys was introduced into the Florida Senate on March 8th, according to the State of Florida's Government Website. You can view the entire text of the bill HERE
If you are wondering what you can do to help get the Bill passed, here is a letter received from a White House Brother that encourages EACH AND EVERY WHB to help.
quote
Right now (March) we need to flood the Internet and media services with information about FSB. Our Claims Bill will be presented before the Florida Legislature this month and the more information they are bombarded with, the better our chance of approval. If there were ever a time that we need to unite as a "Brotherhood" or WHB's it's now. Regardless of social standing, each WHB must step up and do his part. Every brother, spouse, family member needs to be on the phone and Internet making calls to newspapers and TV stations or making comments in letters to the Editor sections of their local newspaper about our cause. We must keep the attention focused on Marianna and Okeechobee and the only way to do that is call and write letters. Each and every WHB should write his state Senator and asked "What is your position on supporting the WHB's Claims Bill?". You might even want to make it easier for them to review by sending them a copy of the Claims Bill. Click HERE to obtain a copy (Note to Bryant: I'll add a link when I add the final draft to the site... its already on there, but links are so convenient, i think.). We are providing information on how to find your Senator below. Please write, email or call and ask for their support. Ask everyone you know to do the same! We need to fight for each and every WHB and future child in the Florida DJJ system. -----Bryant Middleton
unquote
Here are the names and addresses for Senators representing Florida:
Nelson, Bill - (D - FL) Class I 716 HART SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510 (202) 224-5274
To email and for other information on Bill Nelson, click HERE
Rubio, Marco - (R - FL) Class III B40A DIRKSEN SENATE OFFICE BUILDING WASHINGTON DC 20510 (202) 224-3041
To email and for other information on Marco Rubio, click HERE
If you (or your family or friends) wish to contact Senators outside the state of Florida, you can click HERE to obtain their contact info.
For information from the State Of Florida Government Website regarding the Claims Bill, click HERE. There is even a box at the top right hand corner you can click to "Track This Bill".
Here is a Summary of the Claims Bill:
SB 44 - Relief/Victims Florida Reform School for Boys/DJJ CLAIMS/GENERAL BILL by Fasano Relief/Victims Florida Reform School for Boys/DJJ: Provides relief for victims who were abused while confined to the Florida Reform School for Boys located in Marianna and Okeechobee. Compensates them for injuries and damages sustained as a result of the abuses perpetrated by the personnel of the reform schools. Provides a limitation on the payment of fees and costs, etc. Effective Date: upon becoming a law\
2 IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENTS - JAN. 2011
FOR ALL WHITE HOUSE BOYS - WHETHER YOU WERE ABUSED AT FLORIDA SCHOOL FOR BOYS (F.S.B.) IN MARIANNA, a.k.a. DOZIER or F.I.S. (Florida Industrial School) or whether you were at OKEECHOBEE *PLEASE *IMMEDIATELY*
READ THE FOLLOWING 2 ANNOUNCEMENTS
ANNOUNCEMENT 1: (added on 1-18-2011)
White House Boys Documentary Film "Teaser".
Below is the link to our 3 minute teaser on the White House Boys project. This is the first step in telling this very important story. Please feel free also to comment at the site.
Below is the link to our 3 minute teaser on the White House Boys project. This is the first step in telling this very important story. Please feel free also to comment at the site.
This teaser is used for financing and to get the word out that we are going to tell this story -- a story the State of Florida would prefer not be told.
Send the link to everyone you know - Here is the link to view the YouTube story: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cfdcGTWI_A Mass market the link and put your comments in the COMMENTS BOX.
Paul Hensler
Producer
Hensler Film LLC
Or you can click on the link below or cut and paste it into the white internet explorer address bar.
- http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cfdcGTWI_A
ANNOUNCEMENT 2:
Attorney, Greg Hoag, made an announcement regarding information they need for the Claims Bill. His letter follows immediately below. If you have any questions, you can also contact Jerry Cooper at 239-542-3831
Quote
Gentlemen:
We have recently met with our lobbyists in Tallahassee, and are hoping to present the claims bill at a legislative committee hearing early this year. In presenting our case to the legislature, we need your assistance.
Please see the list of questions below. If you answer “YES” to ALL questions, please contact our office immediately for further discussion.
#1 – Have you ever received any counseling or treatment from either a psychologist, psychiatrist or licensed mental health counselor?
#2 – Did you discuss the abuse you experienced at FSB during the counseling or treatment?
#3 – Does the doctor or counselor believe the abuse caused mental health issues?
We thank you in advance, and look forward to hearing from you.
Kind regards,
Greg
Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.
Masterson Law Group, P.A.
699 First Avenue North
St. Petersburg, FL 33701
727-896-3641 -- 727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com
Unquote
1-9-11
URGENT LEGAL NEWS! PLEASE READ!
FOR ALL WHITE HOUSE BOYS -
IF YOU WERE ABUSED AT FLORIDA SCHOOL FOR BOYS IN MARIANNA, a.k.a. DOZIER or OKEECHOBEE *PLEASE READ THIS IMMEDIATELY* The letter from the attorney follows. If you have any questions, you can also contact Jerry Cooper at 239-542-3831
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
10-12-10
Here is great info -- please read!
CLAIMS BILL FOR VICTIMS OF THE FLORIDA SCHOOL FOR BOYS
Location:Home >Session >Bills
October 08, 2010
Florida Senate - 2011 (NP) SB 44
By Senator Fasano
11-00028A-11 201144__
1 A bill to be entitled 2 An act for the relief of the victims who were abused 3 while confined to the Florida Reform School for Boys 4 located in Marianna and Okeechobee; providing an 5 appropriation to compensate them for injuries and 6 damages sustained as result of the abuses perpetrated 7 by the personnel of the reform schools; providing a 8 limitation on the payment of fees and costs; providing 9 an effective date. 10 11 WHEREAS, during the 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s, certain minors 12 were sent to the Florida School for Boys located in Marianna and 13 Okeechobee, Florida, and 14 WHEREAS, some of the boys who were sent to those reform 15 schools were severely physically and psychologically abused by 16 the personnel operating the reform schools in Marianna and 17 Okeechobee, and 18 WHEREAS, some of the boys who were physically, 19 psychologically, and sexually abused had been sent to the reform 20 school for “crimes” such as being truant from elementary school, 21 for running away from abusive homes, for running away from 22 foster homes, for being “incorrigible” in an orphanage, for 23 jumping a fence at a city swimming pool, or for smoking, and 24 WHEREAS, many of the boys were not given a trial prior to 25 being sent by the state to the reform schools, and 26 WHEREAS, more than 300 former students of the reform 27 schools have come forward alleging abuses during the 1940s, 28 1950s, and 1960s, and 29 WHEREAS, many beatings were inflicted in a building known 30 as the “White House” at the reform school in Marianna, and 31 WHEREAS, the boys were forced to lie face down on a blood- 32 and urine-stained cot, were told to bite a pillow covered with 33 blood, vomit, and bodily fluids, and 34 WHEREAS, the boys were struck repeatedly (as many as 100 35 strikes) on their buttocks and legs with a leather razor strap 36 with a wooden handle, and 37 WHEREAS, such strikes were given with a full swing from 38 overhead, and 39 WHEREAS, such strikes were given with such force that the 40 strap frequently cut into the boys’ skin, causing bleeding and 41 bruising, and 42 WHEREAS, such strikes frequently caused portions of 43 clothing to become embedded into the skin, requiring pieces of 44 their cotton underwear be extracted from the boys’ flesh, and 45 WHEREAS, school employees imposing the whippings would turn 46 on a large industrial fan to muffle the screams of the boys 47 being beaten, and 48 WHEREAS, the personnel of the reform schools who 49 perpetrated such beatings would make monetary bets on which of 50 them could draw blood first from the boys, and 51 WHEREAS, some victims needed medical treatment following 52 the beatings, and were left with permanent scars, and 53 WHEREAS, some of the boys who were severely beaten were as 54 young as 10 years of age, and 55 WHEREAS, after being beaten, some boys were placed in 56 solitary confinement for as long as 30 days in an approximately 57 8-by-8-foot cell having no lights or windows, containing only a 58 bunk with a mattress and no sheets, and a bucket to be used as a 59 toilet, which was known as the “hole,” and 60 WHEREAS, the boys were segregated at the reform schools 61 into white and black areas, and 62 WHEREAS, both races were subjected to beatings, and 63 WHEREAS, some of the beatings were given as punishment for 64 “violations,” such as eating an extra pancake at breakfast, 65 eating blueberries while running an errand, wearing buttons with 66 the wrong insignia on the jacket, lying about using a curse 67 word, having a “bad attitude,” or smiling at the wrong time, and 68 WHEREAS, on one occasion, a boy was tied between two trees 69 while he was repeatedly kicked in the groin, and 70 WHEREAS, some of the boys were simply pulled out of their 71 beds in the middle of the night for beatings or for sexual 72 assaults, and 73 WHEREAS, some of the boys were raped and otherwise 74 physically and sexually assaulted, including being forced to 75 perform oral sex by the reform school personnel and by 76 supervisors and cottage “fathers,” and 77 WHEREAS, beatings in the Okeechobee facility included 78 strikes with leather straps that had quarters or dimes embedded 79 in the leather to provide extra weight, and assaults using 80 “probing rods” that were made of wood and used for punishment by 81 sodomizing the boys, and 82 WHEREAS, boys were asked sexually inappropriate questions 83 by a school psychologist purportedly hired to counsel the boys, 84 and 85 WHEREAS, boys were sexually assaulted by a “school 86 psychologist,” and 87 WHEREAS, boys were sexually abused by school guards in an 88 underground room called the “rape room,” and 89 WHEREAS, the boys were threatened with their lives by the 90 reform school personnel and told not to tell others of these 91 abuses, and 92 WHEREAS, one of the reform school administrators who is 93 alleged to have beaten many of the children admitted under oath 94 that boys were punished by taking them to the “White House,” 95 that the boy being punished was told to lie face down on a cot 96 in an otherwise empty room, that at times they would have two or 97 three boys from the kitchen hold down the boy being punished, 98 that he hit the boys with a thick leather razor strap with a 99 handle 8 to 10 times per infraction, that he at times witnessed 100 bruises on their buttocks afterward, that the director of the 101 school was always present during the “spankings,” that he 102 witnessed the director and another employee at times giving the 103 “spankings,” that boys could be given such punishment for 104 infractions such as smoking, talking about running away, or 105 having an “attitude problem,” and 106 WHEREAS, the national guidelines for training school and 107 juvenile agencies in the 1960s provided that corporal punishment 108 should not be tolerated in any form, including slapping, 109 spanking, paddling, belting, or any kind of abuse, and 110 WHEREAS, Arthur G. Dozier, a former school superintendent, 111 acknowledged the whippings in 1964 when Mr. Dozier stated to the 112 press that although he did not like the whippings, he would not 113 like to see the Legislature take away the right by completely 114 forbidding whipping, and 115 WHEREAS, the school in Marianna is currently named the 116 Arthur G. Dozier School for Boys, and 117 WHEREAS, the reform schools were severely underfunded 118 causing overcrowding, and, according to the national guidelines 119 of the time, Marianna housed more than five times the number of 120 children recommended for a state training school, and 121 WHEREAS, the underfunding also resulted in inadequate 122 supervision, and, according to the national guidelines of the 123 time, Marianna employed an insufficient number of caseworkers, 124 and 125 WHEREAS, according to the national guidelines of the time, 126 the Marianna school was understaffed in teachers, and 127 WHEREAS, according to the national guidelines of the time, 128 the Marianna school was understaffed in recreation workers, and 129 WHEREAS, according to the national guidelines of the time, 130 the Marianna school was understaffed in psychologists, and 131 WHEREAS, juvenile court judges who toured the school in 132 1969 stated that conditions were dismal, without adequate 133 facilities, without adequate staffing, and sexual perversion was 134 common, and 135 WHERREAS, one judge stated he felt like a rat for sending 136 boys to that place, that by sending boys to the training center 137 they were doing damage as far as sexual problems were concerned, 138 and that eventually he would like to see the place phased out, 139 and 140 WHEREAS, Governor Claude Kirk toured the school in 1968 and 141 stated “If one of your kids were kept in such circumstances, 142 you’d be up there with rifles,” and 143 WHEREAS, Dr. Eugene Byrd, a psychologist and former staff 144 employee, testified in 1958 before the United States Senate that 145 the conditions and beatings of the boys that he witnessed 146 amounted to “brutality,” and 147 WHEREAS, a pattern of abuse at the reform schools has 148 existed for more than 100 years: in 1903, investigators found 149 children in shackles; in 1911, a report of a special joint 150 committee on the reform school stated that the inmates were at 151 times unnecessarily and brutally punished, the instrument of 152 punishment being a leather strap fastened to a wooden handle; 153 and in 1914, at least 10 children died in a fire in the main 154 building of the Marianna reform school, where it was reported 155 that all fire-escape doors were locked, and 156 WHEREAS, similar abuses occurred at the reform schools 157 located in Marianna and Okeechobee and were considered standard, 158 accepted practice and procedure for administering discipline at 159 the schools, and 160 WHEREAS, these children suffered severe physical and 161 psychological damages that have endured throughout their adult 162 lives, causing damages, including, but not limited to: severe 163 depression; post-traumatic stress disorder; persistent insomnia, 164 including an inability to sleep in the dark for many years; 165 substance abuse; phantom pain; and relationship and economic 166 hardships, including, but not limited to, an inability to 167 maintain personal relationships, causing multiple failed and 168 broken marriages and families, violence, prison time, suicide, 169 lack of trust, and an inability to maintain employment, NOW, 170 THEREFORE, 171 172 Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida: 173 174 Section 1. The sum of $...... is appropriated from the 175 General Revenue Fund to the Department of Juvenile Justice for 176 the relief of the victims who were abused while confined to the 177 Florida Reform School for Boys in Marianna and Okeechobee and 178 who sustained injuries and damages as a result of such abuses 179 perpetrated by the personnel of the reform schools. 180 Section 2. The Chief Financial Officer is directed to draw 181 a warrant in favor of the victims who were abused while confined 182 to the Florida Reform School for Boys in Marianna and Okeechobee 183 in the sum of $...... upon funds in the State Treasury, and the 184 Chief Financial Officer is directed to pay the same out of such 185 funds in the State Treasury. 186 Section 3. The Legislature is not deemed by this act to 187 have waived any defense of sovereign immunity or to have 188 increased the limits of liability on behalf of the state or any 189 person or entity subject to the provisions of s. 768.28, Florida 190 Statutes, or any other law. 191 Section 4. The amount awarded under this act is intended to 192 provide the sole compensation for all present and future claims 193 arising out of the factual situation described in this act which 194 resulted in injuries to the victims who were abused while 195 confined to the Florida Reform School for Boys in Marianna and 196 Okeechobee. The total amount paid for attorney’s fees, lobbying 197 fees, costs, and other similar expenses relating to this claim 198 may not exceed 25 percent of the amount awarded under this act. 199 Section 5. This act shall take effect upon becoming a law.
5-12-10
Hey guys, just got an email from the Attorneys. If you didn't receive it via any of the email chains, give them a call or check their website by following the directions below to get filled in on what's new!
MASTERSON LAW GROUP PROVIDES A WAY FOR WHITE HOUSE BOYS' INVOLVED IN THE CLAIM TO CHECK FOR UPDATES ON-LINE. Read On...
Folks,
At long last, the attorneys at Masterson Law Group have finally given us the internet access to updates on the White House Boys Claim, as they had promised us late last year. In order to find the latest news concerning the lawsuit, please contact the Masterson Law Group to obtain a username and password. Tell them you are one of their White House Boys' Clients when you request the password. Here is their contact info:
11-00028A-11 201144__Folks, At long last, the attorneys at Masterson Law Group have finally given us the internet access to updates on the White House Boys Claim, as they had promised us late last year. In order to find the latest news concerning the lawsuit, please contact the Masterson Law Group to obtain a username and password. Tell them you are one of their White House Boys' Clients when you request the password. Here is their contact info:
Masterson Law Group, P.A.
699 First Avenue North
St. Petersburg, Florida 33701
(727) 896-3641
Thomas D. Masterson
TMasterson@Mastersonlaw.com
Gregory J. Hoag
mailto:ghoag@mastersonlaw.com+
Once you have obtained your username and password, then click on the following link:
http://www.masterson-law.com/clientarea/
Put in the username and password you were given, and you can view the latest updates on the case.
Sorry this has taken so long, but the law firm's webmaster worked diligently for us, until completion, in order to fulfil the promise they made us late last year -- to grant us internet access to the latest infomation regarding the case.
UPDATES FROM MASTERSON GROUP
(These are the most recent. We will be adding older updates as time allows)
March 11, 2010
Attached is a copy of FDLE’s investigative report. We will be discussing this with our lobbyists & the legislators. Please feel free to pass along to other clients, and post on your respective websites. Click HERE to view the complete FDLE report.
March 10, 2010
Gentlemen: Attached is the Order of Dismissal. This will be added to our firm website’s case status update page, which is current. Again, please pass this along to other clients, and feel free to post on your respective websites.
Thank you,
Greg
Click HERE to read the letter.
IMPORTANT: You need Adobe to open this file. If you don't already have it on your computer, you can download it HERE for free. (Be sure to uncheck the box that gives you Free McAfee scanner unless you are sure you want that program as well). The Adobe Reader program enables you to open any files that are in a ".pdf" format.
NEWS ABOUT CLAIMS BILL - POSTED 1-25-12
I spoke to Gregory Hoag yesterday and was told that Senator Fasano is attempting to have the claims bill heard during the session that is now going on. There is still 6-7 weeks left on this session, and we can only hope that he will be jubilant in doing so. Jerry Cooper President "The Official White House Boys Organization"
1-25-12 SEE ALSO A SERIES OF EMAILS TO/FROM GREG HOAG AT MASTERSON LAW, JERRY COOPER AND ALSO THE NEW LAW FIRM HOLLAND AND KNIGHT WITH INFO PERTAINING TO THE CLAIMS BILL (Note: The emails are in the order of most recent first, and oldest email last)
-------- Original Message -------- Subject: FW: Claims Bill
Date: Wed, 25 Jan 2012 14:00:09 -0500
From: Gregory Hoag <ghoag@mastersonlaw.com>
Men: Please see below. I would urge you & the others to contact Senator Fasano at 850-487-5062 and fasano.mike.web@flsenate.gov. Everyone needs to first THANK HIM for his support & sponsorship of bill, and then encourage that he try to move the Senate Special Master off his position of having the bill abate, so it can be considered this session.
Please spread the word & keep up the fight!
Thanks!
Greg
Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.
Masterson Law Group, P.A.
-----Original Message-----
From: brad.kimbro@hklaw.com [mailto:brad.kimbro@hklaw.com]
Sent: Wednesday, January 25, 2012 12:09 PM
To: ghoag@mastersonlaw.com; joe.varner@hklaw.com; Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com; bob.martinez@hklaw.com
Cc: tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com; Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: Claims Bill
Greg - Senate Bill (SB) 46 is before the Special Master on Claims Bills. Based on the letters we've received from the Special Master, it might be helpful to have folks call Senator Fasano's office. Their calls should be to support the Senator's efforts but also encourage him to move the Special Master off the current position ultimately allowing the measure to be considered.
Any follow up from Ben Montgomery?
Bradford D. Kimbro | Holland & Knight
Executive Partner - Tampa Bay
-----Original Message-----
From: Gregory Hoag [mailto:ghoag@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Wednesday, January 18, 2012 2:28 PM
To: Kimbro, Bradford D; Varner, Joseph H; Eikenberg, Eric J; Martinez, Bob
Cc: tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com; Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: FW: Claims Bill
Gentlemen:
Please see below, and let me know if there is any news to report to clients on claims bill status.
Thanks,
Greg
Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.
Masterson Law Group, P.A.
-----Original Message-----
From: jerry [mailto:samohi@comcast.net]
Sent: Wednesday, January 18, 2012 12:50 PM
To: Gregory Hoag; Tom Masterson
Subject: Claims Bill
Greg, Can you give me something to post on web on what is going on at this time on Bill?? I am being swamped with guy"s calls!!!
----------------------------------------------------
NEWS FROM THE ATTORNEYS - POSTED 1-13-12
NEWS FROM THE ATTORNEYS - POSTED 1-13-12
Men: The attached is recent email correspondence regarding the claims bill, and the 2nd attachment in particular explains our position in great detail. I would encourage you to contact your local media outlets, and explain the state’s irrational position (as mentioned in the letter & in my earlier email message). We need to expose their position in hopes of putting pressure on the legislators to consider the bill during this session. I appreciate your help. Keep the faith! Regards, Greg Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.
Masterson Law Group, P.A.
699 First Avenue North
St. Petersburg, FL 33701
727-896-3641(phone) 727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com
From: Gregory Hoag
These emails are between Greg Hoag of Masterson Law and Eric Eikenberg of Holland & Knight:
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence
Eric – Thanks for offering to reach out to Sen. Fasano. So it’s easier to forward on, the relevant info is below & attached.
http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/dozier_findltr_12-1-11.pdf
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfZ0spp66WU
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTf6_75GlLo
Thanks,
Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.
Masterson Law Group, P.A.
Subject: Re: FL Senate Correspondence
I think that we should proceed. If Eric knows Senator Fasano on a personal basis, it would probably be best to have a familiar face make contact.
From Eric to Greg: Re: FL Senate Correspondence
I'll defer. Happy to reach out to Fasano.
From: Gregory Hoag
Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 06:00 PM
To: Varner, Joseph and Eric
RE: FL Senate Correspondence
Should we place a call to his office & then follow w/ the email of letters/links to Fasano? I’ll be happy to send, unless someone else planned to initiate the contact. Just let me know.
Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.Masterson Law Group, P.A.
From Joe Varner, HK Law
To: Greg Hoag, Tom Masterson, etc.
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence
I agree.
Joseph H. Varner, III | Holland & Knight
Partner | Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer
100 North Tampa Street, Suite 4100 | Tampa FL 33602
Phone 813.227.6703 | Fax 813.229.0134
Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 5:51 PM
To: Gregory Hoag; 'Tom Masterson'; Varner, Joseph H (TPA - X36703); Martinez, Bob (TPA - X36308); Eikenberg, Eric J (TAL - X35623); Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence Agreed. Unless someone has a concern, I say we go ahead and send this info to Fasano as suggested. Bradford D Kimbro | Holland & Knight
Executive Partner - Tampa Bay
100 North Tampa Street, Suite 4100 | Tampa FL 33602
Phone 813.227.6660 | Fax 813.229.0134
brad.kimbro@hklaw.com | www.hklaw.com ________________________________________________Add to address book | View professional biography From: Gregory Hoag [mailto:ghoag@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Friday, December 09, 2011 10:39 AM
To: 'Tom Masterson'; Kimbro, Bradford D (TPA - X36660); Varner, Joseph H (TPA - X36703); Martinez, Bob (TPA - X36308); Eikenberg, Eric J (TAL - X35623); Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence You’re right. That’s why I said I think we’re free to contact Fasano & others. We might want to consider sending the SP Times article to Fasano along with the video clips below. Pretty good coverage. Take a look. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfZ0spp66WU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTf6_75GlLo Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.Masterson Law Group, P.A.699 First Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33701727-896-3641727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com From: Tom Masterson [mailto:tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Friday, December 09, 2011 10:22 AM
To: 'Gregory Hoag'; brad.kimbro@hklaw.com; joe.varner@hklaw.com; bob.martinez@hklaw.com; Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com; Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence Gentlemen: The final paragraph of the Order of Abeyance says that the abeyance may be waived by the Senate. We need to find out how to accomplish that. In addition, the initial letter from the Special Master says that ex parte communication with the Special Master is prohibited. I do not see anything about communication with the senators. Did I miss something? Tom From: Gregory Hoag [mailto:ghoag@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Friday, December 09, 2011 10:05 AM
To: brad.kimbro@hklaw.com; joe.varner@hklaw.com; bob.martinez@hklaw.com; Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com; tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com; Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence Attached is the correspondence with Senate Special Master re: SB 46. Of note, the last paragraph of the 1st attached letter says “ex-parte communication with the senate special master is prohibited.”We should be permitted to contact Sen. Fasano and other Senate members directly, but let us know what the research reveals & how you want to going about contacting Fasano. Thanks, Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.Masterson Law Group, P.A.699 First Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33701727-896-3641727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com
****IRS CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE: TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH REQUIREMENTS IMPOSED BY THE IRS, WE INFORM YOU THAT ANY TAX ADVICE CONTAINED IN THIS COMMUNICATION (INCLUDING ANY ATTACHMENTS) IS NOT INTENDED OR WRITTEN BY HOLLAND & KNIGHT LLP TO BE USED, AND CANNOT BE USED, FOR THE PURPOSE OF (I) AVOIDING TAX-RELATED PENALTIES UNDER THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE, OR (II) PROMOTING, MARKETING, OR RECOMMENDING TO ANOTHER PARTY ANY TAX-RELATED MATTER HEREIN.****
NOTE: This e-mail is from a law firm, Holland & Knight LLP (“H&K”), and is intended solely for the use of the individual(s) to whom it is addressed. If you believe you received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender immediately, delete the e-mail from your computer and do not copy or disclose it to anyone else. If you are not an existing client of H&K, do not construe anything in this e-mail to make you a client unless it contains a specific statement to that effect and do not disclose anything to H&K in reply that you expect it to hold in confidence. If you properly received this e-mail as a client, co-counsel or retained expert of H&K, you should maintain its contents in confidence in order to preserve the attorney-client or work product privilege that may be available to protect confidentiality.
3 attachments — Download all attachments
SKMBT_C45211120910410.pdf
1056K View Download
SKMBT_C45211120910420.pdf
1396K View Download
SKMBT_C45211120910440.pdf
3202K View Download
YouTube - Videos from this email Reply Reply to all Forward
Charles Fudge
11:12 AM (1 hour ago)
to jerry, babbscooper
please bear with me.. I'm cooking, putting songs on ipod, working with the pastor since he didn't know Junior, and had 20 people visit me unexpectedly last night. Everything will calm down and I'll get to it.
On Thu, Jan 12, 2012 at 7:27 AM, babbscooper@comcast.net <babbscooper@comcast.net> wrote:
POST PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! -------Original Message------- From: jerryDate: 1/11/2012 7:42:02 PMTo: Alan Sexton; apueljr@cox.net; babbs; Ben Elder; Bill Haynes; DickColon@aol.com; Diane; donald smith; Earl Somnitz; jdenykke@yahoo.com; Larry Houston; Mike Sapp; RICHARD NOBLE; RichardD1016@aol.com; THE OFFICIAL WHITE HOUSE BOYS; Willie Robertsjr; WOODS528@aol.com; Charles Fudge; fordsedan56@netzero.net; joe middlebrooks; Martha Somnitz; Tanya Arja; Tom L. HarmonSubject: Fwd: FW: FL Senate Correspondence
-------- Original Message -------- Subject: FW: FL Senate Correspondence
Date: Wed, 11 Jan 2012 16:58:24 -0500
From: Gregory Hoag <ghoag@mastersonlaw.com>
To: <RANGER5988@aol.com>, "Roger Kiser Sr" <trampolineone@hotmail.com>, "Roger Kiser" <trampolineone@yahoo.com>, <rrstraley@hotmail.com>, "jerry" <samohi@comcast.net>, <DickColon@aol.com>
Men: The attached is recent correspondence regarding the claims bill, and the 2nd attachment in particular explains our position in great detail. I would encourage you to contact your local media outlets, and explain the state’s irrational position (as mentioned in the letter & in my earlier email message). We need to expose their position in hopes of putting pressure on the legislators to consider the bill during this session. I appreciate your help. Keep the faith! Regards, Greg Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.Masterson Law Group, P.A.699 First Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33701727-896-3641727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com From: Gregory Hoag [mailto:ghoag@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Tuesday, December 13, 2011 10:24 AM
To: 'tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com'; 'Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com'; 'joe.varner@hklaw.com'; 'brad.kimbro@hklaw.com'; 'bob.martinez@hklaw.com'; 'Mark Buell'
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence Eric – Thanks for offering to reach out to Sen. Fasano. So it’s easier to forward on, the relevant info is below & attached. http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/dozier_findltr_12-1-11.pdf http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfZ0spp66WU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTf6_75GlLo Thanks, Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.Masterson Law Group, P.A.699 First Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33701727-896-3641727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com From: tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com [mailto:tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 8:48 PM
To: Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com; Greg Hoag; joe.varner@hklaw.com; brad.kimbro@hklaw.com; bob.martinez@hklaw.com; Mark Buell
Subject: Re: FL Senate Correspondence I think that we should proceed. If Eric knows Senator Fasano on a personal basis, it would probably be best to have a familiar face make contact. Sent from my Verizon Wireless BlackBerry
From: <Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com> Date: Mon, 12 Dec 2011 23:18:27 +0000To: <ghoag@mastersonlaw.com>; <joe.varner@hklaw.com>; <brad.kimbro@hklaw.com>; <tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com>; <bob.martinez@hklaw.com>; <Subject">Buell@belawtampa.com>Subject: Re: FL Senate Correspondence I'll defer. Happy to reach out to fasano.
--------------------------
Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld
From: Gregory Hoag [mailto:ghoag@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 06:00 PM
To: Varner, Joseph H (TPA - X36703); Kimbro, Bradford D (TPA - X36660); tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com <tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com>; Martinez, Bob (TPA - X36308); Eikenberg, Eric J (TAL - X35623); Buell@belawtampa.com <Buell@belawtampa.com>
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence
Should we place a call to his office & then follow w/ the email of letters/links to Fasano? I’ll be happy to send, unless someone else planned to initiate the contact. Just let me know. Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.Masterson Law Group, P.A.699 First Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33701727-896-3641727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com From: joe.varner@hklaw.com [mailto:joe.varner@hklaw.com]
Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 5:52 PM
To: brad.kimbro@hklaw.com; ghoag@mastersonlaw.com; tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com; bob.martinez@hklaw.com; Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com; Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence I agree. Joseph H. Varner, III | Holland & Knight
Partner | Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer
100 North Tampa Street, Suite 4100 | Tampa FL 33602
Phone 813.227.6703 | Fax 813.229.0134
joe.varner@hklaw.com | www.hklaw.com ________________________________________________
Add to address book | View professional biography From: Kimbro, Bradford D (TPA - X36660)
Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 5:51 PM
To: Gregory Hoag; 'Tom Masterson'; Varner, Joseph H (TPA - X36703); Martinez, Bob (TPA - X36308); Eikenberg, Eric J (TAL - X35623); Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence Agreed. Unless someone has a concern, I say we go ahead and send this info to Fasano as suggested. Bradford D Kimbro | Holland & Knight
Executive Partner - Tampa Bay
100 North Tampa Street, Suite 4100 | Tampa FL 33602
Phone 813.227.6660 | Fax 813.229.0134
brad.kimbro@hklaw.com | www.hklaw.com ________________________________________________Add to address book | View professional biography From: Gregory Hoag [mailto:ghoag@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Friday, December 09, 2011 10:39 AM
To: 'Tom Masterson'; Kimbro, Bradford D (TPA - X36660); Varner, Joseph H (TPA - X36703); Martinez, Bob (TPA - X36308); Eikenberg, Eric J (TAL - X35623); Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence You’re right. That’s why I said I think we’re free to contact Fasano & others. We might want to consider sending the SP Times article to Fasano along with the video clips below. Pretty good coverage. Take a look. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lfZ0spp66WU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTf6_75GlLo Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.Masterson Law Group, P.A.699 First Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33701727-896-3641727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com From: Tom Masterson [mailto:tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Friday, December 09, 2011 10:22 AM
To: 'Gregory Hoag'; brad.kimbro@hklaw.com; joe.varner@hklaw.com; bob.martinez@hklaw.com; Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com; Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence Gentlemen: The final paragraph of the Order of Abeyance says that the abeyance may be waived by the Senate. We need to find out how to accomplish that. In addition, the initial letter from the Special Master says that ex parte communication with the Special Master is prohibited. I do not see anything about communication with the senators. Did I miss something? Tom From: Gregory Hoag [mailto:ghoag@mastersonlaw.com]
Sent: Friday, December 09, 2011 10:05 AM
To: brad.kimbro@hklaw.com; joe.varner@hklaw.com; bob.martinez@hklaw.com; Eric.Eikenberg@hklaw.com; tmasterson@mastersonlaw.com; Buell@belawtampa.com
Subject: RE: FL Senate Correspondence Attached is the correspondence with Senate Special Master re: SB 46. Of note, the last paragraph of the 1st attached letter says “ex-parte communication with the senate special master is prohibited.”We should be permitted to contact Sen. Fasano and other Senate members directly, but let us know what the research reveals & how you want to going about contacting Fasano. Thanks, Gregory J. Hoag, Esq.Masterson Law Group, P.A.699 First Avenue NorthSt. Petersburg, FL 33701727-896-3641727-895-3559 (fax)ghoag@mastersonlaw.com
****IRS CIRCULAR 230 DISCLOSURE: TO ENSURE COMPLIANCE WITH REQUIREMENTS IMPOSED BY THE IRS, WE INFORM YOU THAT ANY TAX ADVICE CONTAINED IN THIS COMMUNICATION (INCLUDING ANY ATTACHMENTS) IS NOT INTENDED OR WRITTEN BY HOLLAND & KNIGHT LLP TO BE USED, AND CANNOT BE USED, FOR THE PURPOSE OF (I) AVOIDING TAX-RELATED PENALTIES UNDER THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE, OR (II) PROMOTING, MARKETING, OR RECOMMENDING TO ANOTHER PARTY ANY TAX-RELATED MATTER HEREIN.****
NOTE: This e-mail is from a law firm, Holland & Knight LLP (“H&K”), and is intended solely for the use of the individual(s) to whom it is addressed. If you believe you received this e-mail in error, please notify the sender immediately, delete the e-mail from your computer and do not copy or disclose it to anyone else. If you are not an existing client of H&K, do not construe anything in this e-mail to make you a client unless it contains a specific statement to that effect and do not disclose anything to H&K in reply that you expect it to hold in confidence. If you properly received this e-mail as a client, co-counsel or retained expert of H&K, you should maintain its contents in confidence in order to preserve the attorney-client or work product privilege that may be available to protect confidentiality.
Reply Reply to all Forward
Click here to Reply, Reply to all, or Forward
Auto Accident AttorneyAds – Why this ad?Auto Accident? Contact us today for a free claim evaluation
ResultsMatterFL.com/Auto-Accident People (3)babbs
babbscooper@comcast.net
Show details
Map this
100 North Tampa Street
Tampa, FL 33602
699 First Avenue North
St Petersburg, FL 33701
Ads – Why these ads?
Sign up for Google Offers
Coming soon - Find great deals in your city from Google Offers.
www.Google.com/offers
Sinkhole Professionals
No Recovery, No Fee. Call Our Sinkhole Adjusters. 1-800-872-0201
www.sinkholeclaim.net
National Aviation Lawyer
Joseph Michael Lamonaca, Esq, ATP FAA Lead Safety Rep, ATP Jet Rated
www.avlaw.us
More about...
Business Law »
Hotmail com »
AOL com »
Sen Video »
12% full
Using 956 MB of your 7668 MB ©2012 Google - Terms & Privacy
Last account activity: 1 hour ago
DetailsYou have 6 new messages.
AN IMPORTANT LETTER FROM DICK COLON, PRESIDENT
The Official White House Boys Organization
P. O. Box 152 · 1616-102 West Cape Coral Parkway
Cape Coral, FL 33914
www.theofficialwhitehouseboys.org
In this house, the State of Florida beat and scarred our bodies, wounded our souls, and dampened our spirits. But now… united…we rise up…and join together to ensure that this history is never, ever repeated!
Officers & Board Members
President Emeritus - Dick Colon
President - Jerry Cooper / Vice President - Nate Dowling
Treasurer - Peggy Marx / Secretary - Babbs Cooper
Sergeant At Arms James M DeNyke
1 January 2012
To All White House Boys and their Families :
First I want to thank all of you who had the confidence to vote me back in as your President for a second term .
But, as you all know, my primary interest is in what is best for the entire group.... In 4 -5 years we were able to do what no one else could do in 105 years -- we closed them down. That will always be the most rewarding achievement I have ever participated in in my life -- to my grave with me it will go!
Having said that, after speaking with several members, I have made a decision to ask Jerry Cooper to step up and help me as Assistant President for various reasons. One is my health, and I'm 2000 miles away from everybody. More important than that is the fact that our effort has started moving at such a fast, even a bit complex pace, that I feel now what we need is someone on the front lines all of the time I have discussed this with the board and they were all 100%.
My reasons for this choice are many As our legal liaison, he is on top of everything everyday and has a great repoire with both law firms and he also has been asked to do (2) interviews, with others in the works. He lives in Florida, where access for him is much more accommodating than for me at 2000 miles away.
Since Jerry is retired, he like Roger Kiser, Robert Straley, and so many others, have devoted much of their time daily for our struggles. He, like some others, is constantly researching information, converses with other members daily, communicates with others -- especially our counsels.
Jerry, like many others, has been at every single reunion, picnic, award ceremony, and all of our donations to both Beacon house and the Eckerd Youth Camp -- as have many of you.
He has done numerous interviews just recently, and to the best of my knowledge, is well liked by all of us WHB's and their families. As your elected president, I feel we need someone with Jerry's knowledge, flexibility and, most of all his loyalty to the WHB's, in Florida, in a position to move forward in our best interest. I am giving Jerry full rein to act on my behalf and will be in constant contact with him. We have finally got the recognition We have so greatly fought for and deserve by keeping ourselves in the face of the public, which is extremely important at this critical time.
I want to thank every one for their faith and trust in me and the cirontinued help and cooperation in the future as we look forward to seeing each other at the next reunion. Though I don't think we'll all be whistling Dixie that soon.
Thank you, Cordially
President
Dick Colon
CONTACT OUR SENATORS! http://www.flsenate.gov/Senators/
CONTACT YOUR HOUSE REPRESENTATIVES! http://www.myfloridahouse.gov/Sections/Representatives/representatives.aspx
USE ROBERT STRALEY'S EMAIL LIST TO CONTACT SENATORS WITHOUT USING THEIR INTERNET FORM: http://www.thewhitehouseboysonline.com/EMAIL-LINKS-HOUSE-REP.html
BE NOTIFIED WHEN THERE IS ANY ACTIVITY ON THE CLAIMS BILL:Florida Senate - 2012 (NP) SB 46
By Senator Fasano
11-00099-12 201246__
1 A bill to be entitled
2 An act for the relief of the victims who were abused
3 while confined to the Florida Reform School for Boys
4 located in Marianna and Okeechobee; providing an
5 appropriation to compensate them for injuries and
6 damages sustained as result of the abuses perpetrated
7 by the personnel of the reform schools; providing a
8 limitation on the payment of fees and costs; providing
9 an effective date.
10
11 WHEREAS, during the 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s, certain minors
12 were sent to the Florida School for Boys located in Marianna and
13 Okeechobee, Florida, and
14 WHEREAS, some of the boys who were sent to those reform
15 schools were severely physically and psychologically abused by
16 the personnel operating the reform schools in Marianna and
17 Okeechobee, and
18 WHEREAS, some of the boys who were physically,
19 psychologically, and sexually abused had been sent to the reform
20 school for “crimes” such as being truant from elementary school,
21 for running away from abusive homes, for running away from
22 foster homes, for being “incorrigible” in an orphanage, for
23 jumping a fence at a city swimming pool, or for smoking, and
24 WHEREAS, many of the boys were not given a trial prior to
25 being sent by the state to the reform schools, and
26 WHEREAS, more than 300 former students of the reform
27 schools have come forward alleging abuses during the 1940s,
28 1950s, and 1960s, and
29 WHEREAS, many beatings were inflicted in a building known
30 as the “White House” at the reform school in Marianna, and
31 WHEREAS, the boys were forced to lie face down on a blood-
32 and urine-stained cot, were told to bite a pillow covered with
33 blood, vomit, and bodily fluids, and
34 WHEREAS, the boys were struck repeatedly (as many as 100
35 strikes) on their buttocks and legs with a leather razor strap
36 that had a wooden handle, and
37 WHEREAS, such strikes were given with a full swing from
38 overhead and were given with such force that the strap
39 frequently cut into the boys’ skin, causing bleeding and
40 bruising, and
41 WHEREAS, such strikes frequently caused portions of
42 clothing to become embedded into the skin, requiring pieces of
43 their cotton underwear be extracted from the boys’ flesh, and
44 WHEREAS, school employees imposing the whippings would turn
45 on a large industrial fan to muffle the screams of the boys
46 being beaten, and
47 WHEREAS, the personnel of the reform schools who
48 perpetrated such beatings would make monetary bets on which of
49 them could draw blood first from the boys, and
50 WHEREAS, some victims needed medical treatment following
51 the beatings and were left with permanent scars, and
52 WHEREAS, some of the boys who were severely beaten were as
53 young as 10 years of age, and
54 WHEREAS, after being beaten, some boys were placed in
55 solitary confinement for as long as 30 days in an approximately
56 8-by-8-foot cell having no lights or windows, containing only a
57 bunk with a bare mattress, and a bucket to be used as a toilet,
58 which was known as the “hole,” and
59 WHEREAS, the boys were segregated at the reform schools
60 into white and black areas, and
61 WHEREAS, both races were subjected to beatings, and
62 WHEREAS, some of the beatings were given as punishment for
63 “violations,” such as eating an extra pancake at breakfast,
64 eating blueberries while running an errand, wearing buttons with
65 the wrong insignia on the jacket, lying about using a curse
66 word, having a “bad attitude,” or smiling at the wrong time, and
67 WHEREAS, on one occasion, a boy was tied between two trees
68 while he was repeatedly kicked in the groin, and
69 WHEREAS, some of the boys were simply pulled out of their
70 beds in the middle of the night for beatings or for sexual
71 assaults, and
72 WHEREAS, some of the boys were raped and otherwise
73 physically and sexually assaulted, including being forced by the
74 reform school personnel, supervisors, and cottage “fathers” to
75 perform oral sex, and
76 WHEREAS, beatings in the Okeechobee facility included
77 strikes with leather straps that had quarters or dimes embedded
78 in the leather to provide extra weight, and assaults using
79 “probing rods” that were made of wood and used for punishment by
80 sodomizing the boys, and
81 WHEREAS, boys were asked sexually inappropriate questions
82 by a school psychologist purportedly hired to counsel the boys,
83 and
84 WHEREAS, boys were sexually assaulted by a “school
85 psychologist,” and
86 WHEREAS, boys were sexually abused by school guards in an
87 underground room called the “rape room,” and
88 WHEREAS, the boys were threatened with their lives by the
89 reform school personnel and told not to tell others of these
90 abuses, and
91 WHEREAS, one of the reform school administrators who is
92 alleged to have beaten many of the children admitted under oath
93 that boys were punished by taking them to the “White House,” and
94 WHEREAS, this reform school administrator further admitted
95 under oath that personnel would tell these boys to lie face down
96 on a cot in an otherwise empty room and would have two or three
97 boys from the kitchen hold down the boy being punished, and
98 WHEREAS, the reform school administrator admitted under
99 oath that he hit the boys with a thick leather razor strap that
100 had a handle 8 to 10 times per infraction, that he at times
101 witnessed bruises on their buttocks afterward, that the director
102 of the school was always present during the “spankings,” that he
103 witnessed the director and another employee at times giving the
104 “spankings,” that boys could be given such punishment for
105 infractions such as smoking, talking about running away, or
106 having an “attitude problem,” and
107 WHEREAS, the national guidelines for training school and
108 juvenile agencies in the 1960s provided that corporal punishment
109 should not be tolerated in any form, including slapping,
110 spanking, paddling, belting, or any kind of abuse, and
111 WHEREAS, Arthur G. Dozier, a former school superintendent,
112 acknowledged the whippings in 1964 when Mr. Dozier stated to the
113 press that although he did not like the whippings, he would not
114 like to see the Legislature take away the right by completely
115 forbidding whipping, and
116 WHEREAS, the school in Marianna is currently named the
117 Arthur G. Dozier School for Boys, and
118 WHEREAS, the reform schools were severely underfunded
119 causing overcrowding, and
120 WHEREAS, according to the national guidelines of the time,
121 Marianna housed more than five times the number of children
122 recommended for a state training school, and
123 WHEREAS, the underfunding also resulted in inadequate
124 supervision, and
125 WHEREAS, according to the national guidelines of the time,
126 Marianna employed an insufficient number of caseworkers, and
127 WHEREAS, according to the national guidelines of the time,
128 the Marianna school was understaffed in teachers, recreation
129 workers, and psychologists, and
130 WHEREAS, juvenile court judges who toured the school in
131 1969 stated that conditions were dismal, without adequate
132 facilities, without adequate staffing, and sexual perversion was
133 common, and
134 WHERREAS, one judge stated that he felt like a rat for
135 sending boys to that place, that by sending boys to the training
136 center they were doing damage as far as sexual problems were
137 concerned, and that eventually he would like to see the place
138 phased out, and
139 WHEREAS, Governor Claude Kirk toured the school in 1968 and
140 stated “If one of your kids were kept in such circumstances,
141 you’d be up there with rifles,” and
142 WHEREAS, Dr. Eugene Byrd, a psychologist and former staff
143 employee, testified in 1958 before the United States Senate that
144 the conditions and beatings of the boys that he witnessed
145 amounted to “brutality,” and
146 WHEREAS, a pattern of abuse at the reform schools has
147 existed for more than 100 years: in 1903, investigators found
148 children in shackles; in 1911, a report of a special joint
149 committee on the reform school stated that the inmates were at
150 times unnecessarily and brutally punished with a leather strap
151 fastened to a wooden handle; and in 1914, at least 10 children
152 died in a fire in the main building of the Marianna reform
153 school where it was reported that all fire-escape doors were
154 locked, and
155 WHEREAS, similar abuses occurred at the reform schools
156 located in Marianna and Okeechobee and were considered standard,
157 accepted practice and procedure for administering discipline at
158 the schools, and
159 WHEREAS, these children suffered severe physical and
160 psychological damages that have endured throughout their adult
161 lives, including, but not limited to: severe depression; post
162 traumatic stress disorder; persistent insomnia, including an
163 inability to sleep in the dark for many years; substance abuse;
164 phantom pain; relationship and economic hardships, including,
165 but not limited to, an inability to maintain personal
166 relationships causing multiple failed and broken marriages and
167 families; violence; prison time; suicide; lack of trust; and an
168 inability to maintain employment, NOW, THEREFORE,
169
170 Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida:
171
172 Section 1. The sum of $...... is appropriated from the
173 General Revenue Fund to the Department of Juvenile Justice for
174 the relief of the victims who were abused while confined to the
175 Florida Reform School for Boys in Marianna and Okeechobee and
176 who sustained injuries and damages as a result of such abuses
177 perpetrated by the personnel of the reform schools.
178 Section 2. The Chief Financial Officer is directed to draw
179 a warrant in favor of the victims who were abused while confined
180 to the Florida Reform School for Boys in Marianna and Okeechobee
181 in the sum of $...... upon funds in the State Treasury, and the
182 Chief Financial Officer is directed to pay the same out of such
183 funds in the State Treasury.
184 Section 3. The Legislature is not deemed by this act to
185 have waived any defense of sovereign immunity or to have
186 increased the limits of liability on behalf of the state or any
187 person or entity subject to the provisions of s. 768.28, Florida
188 Statutes, or any other law.
189 Section 4. The amount awarded under this act is intended to
190 provide the sole compensation for all present and future claims
191 arising out of the factual situation described in this act which
192 resulted in injuries to the victims who were abused while
193 confined to the Florida Reform School for Boys in Marianna and
194 Okeechobee. The total amount paid for attorney’s fees, lobbying
195 fees, costs, and other similar expenses relating to this claim
196 may not exceed 25 percent of the amount awarded under this act.
197 Section 5. This act shall take effect upon becoming a law.
************************
1-9-11
Here is the Florida Claims Bill
Senate 0044:
Relating to Relief/Victims Florida Reform School for Boys/DJJ
S44 CLAIM BILL/GENERAL by Fasano
Relief/Victims Florida Reform School for Boys/DJJ;
Provides relief for victims who were abused while confined to the Florida Reform School for Boys located in Marianna and Okeechobee. Compensates them for injuries and damages sustained as a result of the abuses perpetrated by the personnel of the reform schools. Provides a limitation on the payment of fees and costs, etc. CLAIM WITH APPROPRIATION: Indeterminate EFFECTIVE DATE: upon becoming a law. To read the entire bill, click this link:
http://www.flsenate.gov/session/index.cfm?Mode=Bills&SubMenu=1&Tab=session&BI_Mode=ViewBillInfo&BillNum=0044&Chamber=Senate&Year=2011&Title=-%3EBill%2520Info%3AS%25200044-%3ESession%25202011
**********************
Please read the Newspaper and TV Stories page and tell us what YOU think by adding a comment to the guestbook!
TO READ THE FDLE REPORT CLICK HERE
Here is the opinion of Robert Straley as to the FDLE report concerning the abuse allegations:
I found the report fair, in the following respects: that they did mention staff members, who had witnessed beatings or saw the results, stating that they felt the beatings were extreme, and /or , some had seen blood on the boys clothes, or bodies.
However, I found the report to be extremely bias and composed to favor the State. Much attention was given to the beatings as being: "acceptable for the time" that it was legal at the time to punish boys with the whip, and played down the tone of the beatings themselves so that the reader would assume that the allegations of 50 to 100 lashes were merely embellishment on the victims part.
Flogging with leather whips was banned in 1922 by Governor Hardee when Martin Tabert, a young man of 22 was whipped to death in a Florida labor camp. It was labeled "Florida's Disgrace" and the uproar it caused resulted in the Governor's ban. However, the same instrument of punishment was used on boys as young as nine to seventeen years of age in the Florida School for Boys for the next 45 years. It was finally stopped in 1968 by Oliver J. Keller, head of the new State Youth Services Agency-- he banned the strap and paddles. Note: This was done under Governor Claude Kirk's administration.
One has to bear in mind that the Florida Department of Law Enforcement is an entity controlled by the state. The state also is funding the defense of Troy Tidwell, one of the most notorious Whip Masters. How can we expect that an investigation, carried out by the state's own entity would result in a judgment or charges against the state?
They have done the same thing they did in the investigation of the 32 unmarked graves. Not one grave was dug up, no ground penetrating radar or cadaver dogs were used, it was merely explained away on paper. Even so, they had to admit that at one time the crosses have been removed and then placed back in the graveyard by guess work only.
In a St. Petersburg Times report by Ben Montgomery and Waveney Ann Moore:
According to the school's records, at least 50 more boys who died here remain unaccounted for. In the end, the FDLE determined that 81 people died there, but the official records placed just 31 in the cemetery on the hill. For 60 years, the school had a black campus and a white campus. In the first half of the last century, it was uncommon for blacks and whites to be buried together. But FDLE found no records to suggest there was more than one cemetery.
"We're basing our findings on records, family members, former students themselves," Perez (of the FDLE) said. "Without the evidence to support it, we just don't know."
Without a way to see underground, without proper headstones or a reliable body count, there is only speculation. Perez said the FDLE published the names of the other 50 boys in hopes of generating clues about their whereabouts.
This report follows in the same thread. The report smacks of being superficial and trivial in nature, there is a huge omission of testimony and facts, not to mention the history of the school, in which these abuses are well documented all the way back to 1903. In that time in which we were there, in the 50s and 60s, there were many visits by senators, judges, governors, all which reported that the school was the worst example of a reform school in the nation, called it "A Monstrosity," 1400 Acres of Hell, all in all there are 22 newspaper archive reports that have been open to the public since at least 1958 and are listed on our web site: http://whitehouseboys.com . Many back up our allegations to the hilt. The only archive material I found in this report was the history of the school and a picture of Mr. O. J. Keller, holding one of the straps and a paddle that the boys were punished with.
TESTIMONY FROM STATE OFFICIALS AND NEWSPAPER ARCHIVES
Testimony of Doctor Eugene Byrd
Dr. Eugene Byrd, a Miami psychologist who had worked at the Florida School for Boys, was called on March 4, 1958, to give testimony before the U.S. Senate's committee on the judiciary.
Mr. MITLER. What did the building look like?
Dr. BYRD. A very small building, formerly used for solitary confinement. It has since had the grills removed. It would be approximately a 20- by l0-foot square and is located next to the dining hall. As I indicated, the boys are taken there once a week on Saturday right before the lunch period.
Mr. MITLER. What did you see?
Dr. BYRD. There are 2 rooms, 1 room in which they weighed in, the other room in which they are beat consists of a cot on which they lay down. They are told to hold the head rail and not yell out nor to move. They are beaten by the director of the department, not the superintendent of the school. The superintendent does witness each beating.
Mr. MITLER. Are the blows severe or mild?
Dr. BYRD. The blows are very severe. They are dealt with a great deal of force with a full arm swing over his head and down, with a strap, a leather strap approximately a half inch thick and about 10 inches long with a wooden formed handle. Each boy received a minimum of 15. All boys reported this, and the times I witnessed it, there was no boy who received less than 15 at that time. As I indicated and have a material chart here, I was interested in who was getting these beatings, since there was a very young boy at this time, about age 10, who was unable to hold the bed and received approximately 22 lashes.
Senator KEFAUVER. Go ahead, sir.
Dr. BYRD. Do you want to refer to the chart?
After this is done the boy is told to get up, shake hands with the superintendent, and go on out in a group. This constitutes the actual punishment.
Senator KEFAUVER. What is your opinion? Dr. BYRD. In my personal opinion it is brutality.
From the Miami News March 4, 1958 "Routine Beatings"
A boy to be beaten must lie down on a narrow hospital bed, stretch his arms above his head, and hold onto the bed. He buries his face in a pillow across his arm. A staff member then beats him with a leather strap 22 inches long, 4" wide and a half inch thick. The beatings are called paddling's, Dr. Byrd explains, but they are beatings delivered with the full force of a grown man.
They wear out the straps on the boys. Assistant Superintendent R.W. Hatton does most of this, while Superintendent Art Dozier or Assistant Superintendent H.B. Mitchell, count the blows. Hatton swings his arm all the way over his head and down with force. There's a rhythm to the blows, comments Dr. Byrd. Boys are hit on the buttocks. They must not turn loose of the bars or scream or move. If they do, the licks they have been given don't count. They are allowed to cry.
From The Miami News Feb 26, 1969 "Spare The Rod And..."
The superintendent or, his assistant, or the director of one of the departments takes a strap from a hook on the wall. The individual administering the punishment doubles the strap and very slowly raised over his head. The shadow is clearly thrown on the wall. The boy on the bed sees it, mentally stiffens.The belt falls between 8 and 100 times. After about the tenth stroke, the seams of the sturdiest blue jeans begin to separate and numerous times the boy's skin is broken to the extent stitches are required. That report was from a former House father at Marianna, now personnel manager at another Florida institution. He says: the strap was wielded by a man who was at least 6'3" and weighed well over 200 pounds. His swing could be likened to a strong tennis serve with a whip-like effect at the end of the downswing. "The results are sickening. The child quivers and writhes in a contorted manner from the pain of a sadistic treatment, not only repulsive but somewhat criminal in nature."
Another supervisor who trained for a year at Marianna described a boy's buttocks as: "bleeding profusely: the skin was broken....."
From the Miami News March 5, 1958
"Beatings Shock Collins"
Art Dozier, Superintendent of Marianna, has conceded that boys are regularly paddled with a leather strap. Gov. Collins asked to comment on reports of mass beatings, said today he would reserve final judgment. "I can't believe that there is any brutality going on or that Mr. Dozier would be permitting anything wrong," the Governor said.
"I wasn't aware they use corporal punishment, and I never knew the beatings, I have to side against the use of corporal punishment. I don't approve of it."
"Corporal punishment in my estimation is passé, commented R.A. McFarland, Head of the Sheriff's Juvenile Aid Bureau. "According to the civil rights laws you can't beat an adult. Why allow the beating of children?"
From the Miami News March 5, 1958
Beatings "Only Weapon Effective On Bad Boys"
Florida law does not permit corporal punishment of adults in jails. It does allow children to be whipped, strapped and paddled.
Corporal punishment should not be tolerated in any form, says the Children's Bureau of the US Department of Health, Education and Welfare, in preparing "Guides and Goals" for institutions serving delinquent children.
It was well known for years that boys were being abused in a harsh and extreme manner at FSB. Many people in the town of Marianna had this knowledge as well, however, due to their collusion with the school over jobs and money, the citizenry has remained silent. The simple fact is that no one in the town of Marianna has found the courage to stand up and acknowledge that the stories are true.This gives me the feeling that they are responsible as well, their silence alone is a collusion to the abuse that occurred there.
After searching the article, as to the beatings, I find there is no mention of any other boy/man other than the original four White House boys, Roger Kiser, Robert Straley, Michael O. McCarthy and Dick Colon. There are probably 75 to 100 men that received worse beatings than the above mentioned. Donald Smith and Jerry Cooper, each received well over 150 lashes, yet they are not mentioned. Jerry Cooper, at his own expense, took a lie detector test to confirm that his allegations were true. He passed the test and challenged Troy Tidwell to take a lie detector test as well. He was also taken to a FDLE lab and test for residual scarring which came up positive.
In Tidwell's statements of the beatings he says: "I never gave more than 10 gentle blows." The fact that they only mentioned abuse concerning the original four White House Boys shows that it is only an attempt to destroy our character and credibility, especially due to the fact that they each control web sites with much information concerning the abuses. What of the boys who suffered much worse? Are their stories of less importance?
Superintendent Lenox, Williams stated that the students received 10 to 12 licks at the most. Former Home Life Supervisor William Mitchell stated that he was present during the spankings and students received 5 to 10 licks at most. Troy Tidwell stated that 10 licks were the maximum for even the most serious offenses. In his deposition Tidwell describes the lashes as being 10 gentle lashes. The same as he would use on his own children. I personally, did not receive any of those gentle lashes. I have not spoken with any other FSB child inmates that did.
Even though the report contained statements by several former cottage fathers that the beatings were extreme and there was blood on some boys, the repeated statements of the number of licks as being 5 to 10 is the most outrageous and outstanding lie in the whole of this document. To trivialize these beatings is the worst mistake that the FDLE has committed thus far. This will only anger the men who suffered these beatings and will only cause them to be more resolute in their efforts for justice. Having read many comments at the bottom of news stories, the bulk of the comments were negative where the FDLE's report was concerned, so the citizenry of Florida are not necessarily buying their story.
HERE IS A LIST OF MEN WHO AS BOYS DID NOT RECEIVE 10 GENTLE BLOWS
LIST OF BOYS BY NAME, AGE, NUMBER OF LASHES, NAME OF WHIPPER, COMMENTS, WhipMasters by Last Name
Note: This list consists of 58 men who sent in their stories. There are 242+ that have not sent in stories, but the lawyers have their names and I am sure they will testify as to the beatings they received. As you will note there is not one boy who received the "ten gentle licks during what the FDLE described as "Spankings" As Dr Byrd said as he testified during the U.S. Senate's Committee on the Judiciary: "In my personal opinion it is brutality."
Jerry Cooper 135 lashes By: Tidwell
Jim James 80 Lashes By: Tidwell
Don Smith 164 Lashes 67 lashes then 97 lashes (for talking of beating), same day By: Walters & Williams. Cottage Father Hollon threatened to go to authorities, left 30 days later.
Bill Haynes 145 Lashes: 45 lashes then 100 By Tidwell & Hatton on same day
Freddie J. Williams 100 lashes By: Crockett
Frank Marz 16 yrs old 100+ Lashes
Billy Foote 63 lashes By: Burgress Has scars
Arthur Huntley 12 yrs old 75 lashes
Harold Sizemore 8 yrs old 30+ Lashes By: Hatton
Freddy Surber 11 yrs old 40 Lashes with a board By: Hatton w/Marino as witness, 15 lashes on another beating.
Jim Blount 12 yrs old 20+ By: Hatton / Dozier Witness
Clifford Hastings 50+ lashes By Hatton Sent to Hospital
Willie Roberts 52 Lashes By: Unknown
Paul Waldron 12 yrs old 70 Lashes Taken to Hospital on stretcher. Has Scars
Manuel Giddens 46 Lashes By: Hatton
Patrick Hogan 15 yrs old 50+ Lashes By: White
James McKinley Mutter 100 Lashes By: Hatton and beaten with fists to groin, taken to hospital, stitches in head, swollen testicles, in Hospital 3 days. Mother of another boy took pictures, he was given 25 more lashes by Hatton and told to keep quiet.
George Stalvey 14 yrs old 65 Lashes By: Tidwell Taken to Hospital
Larry Houston 14 yrs old 39+ By:____
Captain Phillip Savill 14 yrs old 45 Lashes By: Tidwell / Williams as Witness plus another beating for talking about the whipping and 30 days solitary.
Stu Kruger 15 yrs old 37-40 Lashes By: Hatton Taken to Hospital, two days to walk.
C.E. Gene Rogers Jr. 82 Lashes for Running BY: Tidwell
Joe Middlebrooks 75 Lashes By: Hatton / Tidwell Witness
Jimmy Turner 22 Lashes By: Burgess
Daniel Holloway 14 yrs old 30 Lashes By:_____ Plus 60 days solitary for running.
Charles Taylor 15 yrs old 52 Lashes By: Hatton / Dozier witness
Richard Paul Markwalter 27 lashes 1st Time, 52 Lashes 2nd Time Skin Broken & Bleeding
Ron Pesce 12 yrs old Beaten Bloody w/wooden paddle w/Holes
Dennis Kimball 15 yrs old 45 lashes By: Hatton / Tidwell Witness
Jonathan Coker 14 yrs old 26 Lashes By Tidwell, 29 BY: Hatton (split skin), 25 Lashes By: Zitch
Ellis Edwards 11 yrs old 15 Lashes+ By: Tidwell / Walters Witness
Frank O'Conner 25 Lashes By: Tidwell
Bob Baxter 25 w/wooden board then 50 w/same Hospital 3 days Scars. Notes that the wooden board was worse than the whip as he had experienced both.
Thomas Halstead 38 Lashes By: Hatton / Borkhart Cottage Father Witness
Phillip Martin Went Down 10 Times, Beaten Bloody By: Tidwell, Miller, Crockett
Samuel Weese 17 yrs old 25 Lashes By: Tidwell / Williams Witness Two other beatings of 25 Lashes.
Eric Utley 40 Lashes Twice By: Williams, 45 Lashes by: Tidwell / Williams Witness
Manuel Giddens 46 Lashes By: Hatton
John King 12 yrs old Whipped 4 times, had to hold down boys 8 times.
Ski St. Clair 30 Lashes By: Tidwell
John Bennett 17 Lashes By: Tidwell and 23 More by Tidwell
Jimmy Turner 15 yrs old 20 Lashes
Michael Brandenburg 140 Lashes for running-Held down by kitchen boys Hospital 1 week.
Carl Ford 50+ By: White / Miller Witness
Paul Elgin 35 Lashes Two Times
Roy Blanchard 10 yrs old Beather and kicked by other boys at the request of the supervisor on duty
David Vaughn 20 Lashes By: Hatton
Floyd N. Williams 13 yrs old 10 trips to whitehouse By: Hatton & Dozier
Blue Thomas Smith 14 yrs old 30 Lashes By: Tidwell / Davis Witness solidary 11 days
Walter Homman 15 yrs old 15 Lashes, 29 Lashes BY' Hatton / Dioxon Witness 45 Lashes By: Dixon
Charles Fudge 11 yrs old Beaten By: Tidwell & Hatton
Charles S. Taylor 15 yrs old 52 Lashes By: Hatton/ Dozier Witness
Charles Wayne Howard 15 yrs old 30 Lashes Has 4" Scar
Gene Luker 12 yrs old 35 Lashes Solatiry 6 Weeks
Randall Morgan Steed 16 yrs old 40 Lashes at Gunpoint
Frank Richard Wells 31 Lashes By: Tidwell
Alan N. Sexton 14 yrs old 37 Lashes By: Tidwell / Hatton Witness
Phillip Marchesani Ran twice, beaten in woods after the ban on whipping at FSB
RESIDUAL SCARING ISSUE
The FDLE leans very heavily on the phrase "residual scaring." In my opinion, except for some of the extreme beatings, such as the 100 lash beating for running away, at our younger age then, I believe the skin would have healed, so as to leave no scarring. I think a physician or specialist should be consulted as to whether or not a beating given at that age would have left any residual scarring. I notice that there was no mention of this particular aspect being investigated. Where is their medical evidence or statement by a certified physician in this subject? Why were other men who reported scarring not tested? I intend to investigate this immediately.
IGNORE THE LAWYERS ?
I also notice there was no reference whatsoever to any of the six items in the lawyer's letter of January 19, 2010, which included 12 client affidavits, numerous newspaper articles, a 1958 Senate hearing transcript in a 1943 letter from Dozier her to a parent acknowledging the use of corporal punishment at FSB.
A STATEMENT THE FDLE WILL NEVER PRINT
I noticed there was no acknowledgment of this statement made by Sheila Wexler, who was Dr. Wexler's daughter. His daughter remembers helping her father, who had poor eyesight, when their family lived on campus. Sheila Wexler says she occasionally treated boys who had cuts or welts on their behind. "But if they needed a stitch, It would the only be a few." Would you beat your child until they only needed to use stitches? A casual, horrific statement shows the mind set of the staff at Marianna, as openly stated by Dr. Wexler's own daughter. A statement that supports the victims allegations of savage beatings.
THE STRAP
As to the allegations that the strap was weighted with sheet metal, I cannot say that I saw this personally, I did hear from other boys who stated that they did see the metal. When I was beaten the force of the blow drove me down at least one foot into the spring mattress, and I made the mistake of looking to see what in the world was hitting me with such force. For that I received an extra 10 lashes.
AN UNBALANCED REPORT
In a report, several boys were quoted as having to have said that they got what they deserved, or were in no way traumatized, or that no student was ever sent to the White House without a specific cause. In the report there are six comments of this nature. When the story broke, I received phone calls from over 100 men, out of that I can only remember three that said they were not traumatized by the whippings. If you take the five examples that the state notes in the report and put that up against 294 other men, one can see that there is a very large discrepancy. Yet somehow, the writer of this document seems to be able to almost balance this out, yet again lending a trivial slant as to the severity of the beatings. It is so obvious, one has to ask if the writer of this document sees all people as uneducated and stupid. Six out of 294 men does not represent a majority, yet the document presses this issue as if it did.
As to Robert Straley's experience in the rape room, it is what was left out that was the most upsetting to me. I consider what they have to say, as well as Commissioner Gerald M. Bailey, to be a personal attack on my character, and testimony. They made no mention of the fact that when Tidwell was on my back with his knees, that I was unable to breath and passed out, or that I told them I felt that the men were afraid they have caused me grievous harm and took me immediately back to the cottage.
I told Mr. Tom Berlinger right up front that I could not remember every detail of that night. The remark: "I'm sure they did something but I really don't know what, it was" was probably an offhand remark. To use that one remark out of a three hour deposition, I consider to be most underhanded.
During the three-hour deposition, only 10 to 15 minutes were recorded. Nearly everything I had to say about the rape room and Tidwell was off the record, I am assuming, since they did not have the recorder on. My deposition was taken by Mr. Tom Berlinger.I found him to be most courteous and understanding during what was an emotional and trying ordeal. I do not believe that Mr. Berlinger is the type of man that would have prepared this statement where my testimony was concerned. I believe it was done by somebody else in the department. I also turned over a copy of my database, unedited, a years worth of work, so as to help them in any manner in their investigation.
I cannot comment on the death in the laundry room section. I was not there at that time.
BLOOD EVIDENCE, AN IMPORTANT ISSUE
As to the White House, building forensic analysis, I believe the rooms in which the beatings occurred would have been pressure washed long ago, when the beatings were stopped. One former inmate who visited the Dozier campus after the Sealing of the Whitehouse Ceremony found there was at least 3" of water standing on the floor. He was told this was the result of a rainstorm. Mold, of which was certainly present in the whitehouse building and, combined with water, would possibly render any findings of blood residue nil. I would like to hear some other opinions from forensic experts as to the water, mold, and passage of time issue.
BLOOD EVIDENCE WAS SEEN
From the St. Petersburg Times Oct 1, 2008
State Senate President Louis de la Parte
Blood was observed by the Florida Senate President: when the director of the state's reform school for boys in Marianna was fired for whipping children, then reinstated by a powerful politician, Florida Senate President Louis de la Parte drove to the school and found the blood-splattered shed where the abuse had occurred. Tampa Bay Online - Oct 2, 2008
From the St. Petersburg Times Oct 1, 2008 (about Louis de la Parte)
His messages were sometimes unpopular, always sincere. Once, when legislation didn't go his way, he was quoted saying this of the others: "I'm sorry that they feel in their hearts that this is the best we can do."
"He's (Louis de la Parte) one of the finest persons ever to serve in Florida government," said former Florida Gov. Reubin Askew. "He was very bright, courageous, and fought often for causes that weren't otherwise popular. He was really one of my all-time favorites in state government."
INVESTIGATIVE FINDINGS
As to the last article entitled investigative findings: There was an area of disagreement between the students as to the severity of the beatings. This is white wash in its purest form, as they are putting the testimony of six men against 294 men, which is certainly unbalanced. Some students stated that mentally they suffered no harm, yet others attest they suffered greatly, and do so to this day. The same unbalanced view is presented in these statements, six students, who suffered no harm against the word of 294, who say they did suffer harm.
All in all, they did throw in a few negative facts in order to create a seemingly balanced statement. However, the extremely biased and self-serving report is a slap in the face to all of the men that suffered the beatings. Why has Tidwell not been charged with abuse charges when there at least 100 men who will testify they were beaten bloody by him? What is wrong with this justice system? How could the State of Florida ban whipping for hardened adult convicts yet use it on children for 45 more years? What is wrong with this picture?
These reports are in no way going to impede our movement towards justice. Hopefully, if we do receive justice, it may create a piece of legislature or change a law that will benefit children that are currently institutions. Even if we lose legally much has happened that has had a positive effect. The abuse at Dozier has been cut down and abuse at other institutions has declined as well as no other institution wants to find it's self under the same scrutiny as Dozier. Daughters, sons, wives, sisters and brothers of some of the victims have found insight into why their dad or husband acted as he did, was unable to express love or maintain a healthy relationship with his children or, in some cases, abused them. Many have found relief and closure upon finally, after many years, discovering why their father or husband was haunted by something he would not talk about. Most of the men I talked to, after the nationwide news broke, had never mentioned Marianna.
The real driving force behind my journey to expose the truth at FSB is the fact that the State of Florida banned the flogging of male prisoners in 1922, yet let that punishment be doled out to children for the next 45 years. This seems legally impossible, yet the statute of limitations and sovereign immunity stand like iron gates---refusing real justice. Terrible things done to children in the dark and the guilty walks free.
I cannot understand how the State of Florida or the people of Florida, or the Government of Florida could let this go on for as long as it did. It's simply flies in the face of reason and morality. The children of Florida, even in that time period, did not deserve this abuse. I was there in 1963, Kennedy was in office, it was an enlightened age yet children in this era were treated no better than slaves in the 1800's, imprisoned and flogged without mercy, hidden from sight in a small Florida panhandle town. The boys just called it Marianna. Since the State has failed to render justice in any manner it is left to us to continue the fight. There has been talk of closing the school, yet no one seems to grasp the obvious: Remove the children and replace them with adults. Adults have more rights than children. No jobs would be lost. Children do not need to be confined in an institution with an abuse record that rivals any in the whole of the United States.
THE WHIP IS IN OUR HANDS NOW
***************************************************
THE FOLLOWING IS A REPLY FROM BILL HAYNES: